tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post3952431647662009590..comments2023-10-22T01:15:54.689+11:00Comments on Games Lecture: Team MFlorian 'Floyd' Muellerhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/17545757857242519792noreply@blogger.comBlogger48125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-860424863484085242009-06-16T14:15:51.150+10:002009-06-16T14:15:51.150+10:00In the beginning i didn't warm to the idea com...In the beginning i didn't warm to the idea completely. It's not that whole "OMFG HOW CAN YOU MAKE A GAME ABOUT SOMETHING SO LAME AS CLEANING!?!" coz there's games about lamer things. Like farming. I would rather clean a house than clean horse shit.<br /><br />ANYWAY basically what i'm trying to say is, through your presentation you made me believe that a game about cleaning is actually fun.<br /><br />I would play it... but probably not for that long. There isn't that much exertion, and you need something more than just cat and mouse between 2 players to make it more fun.<br />Perhaps a multiplayer mode like left for dead (i think kidney said this) where you have a team of cleaners and a team of messer-upper dudes.<br /><br />over all i like it though.<br /><br />Physical Exertion: 5/10<br />Mind Body Conflict/loop: 7/10<br />Social: 7/10<br />Emotion: 8/10<br />Performance: 7/10<br />Originality: 8/10<br />Style: 6/10<br />Presentation: 10/10<br />Website: 7/10<br />Conclusion: 7/10<br /><br />i think that be a D.Andrew "Dooshie" Demetriounoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-59517315756477005452009-06-12T10:48:00.151+10:002009-06-12T10:48:00.151+10:00Apologies for missing the presentation! although i...Apologies for missing the presentation! although i was talking to trevor before hand about it.. i like the cleaning idea its good and like carla said orginal D for me tooamanda joynoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-2489930736083206302009-06-11T23:00:34.302+10:002009-06-11T23:00:34.302+10:00I missed this presentation too. Again, I went outs...I missed this presentation too. Again, I went outside and didn't come back in time to sit in my seat before you guys started presenting.<br /><br />Anywho! The whole cleaning being turned into a game concept is quite original and interesting.<br /><br />I can't properly mark you but I think : D.<br />Carla.CARLAnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-29788186333375447832009-06-11T22:12:02.967+10:002009-06-11T22:12:02.967+10:00sorry for the late reply:
idea: 3/5
exertion: 4/5...sorry for the late reply:<br /><br />idea: 3/5<br />exertion: 4/5<br />emotion:4/5<br />performance: 3/5<br />social: 5/5<br />presentation: 4/5<br />website: 4/5<br /><br />overall score: Di got a crush on you ;)https://www.blogger.com/profile/02360316207219121914noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-38689624806167222812009-06-11T21:07:00.210+10:002009-06-11T21:07:00.210+10:00Okay i'm giving you a distinction. Not because...Okay i'm giving you a distinction. Not because i've given all the others that - i've meant every mark i've given. But because you put in no less effort of thought into your game than the others...you're just catering for a different audience and your game is in a different league.<br />The one criticism i do have is how physical you can get, as this game doesn't quite get the heart pumping as much as the others, but i won't hold this against you as i found this point and the line as to how physical it should be rather vague too.<br />On the note of why wiiclean when you can realclean, it's different, it's a game! You can win or lose, there's a challenge there would be consequences, CUSTOMISABLE HATS. In RL, you can't win or lose, either you clean it or you get sidetracked but this is not the same!...<br />But mind you if you could lose in RL, i would still be on the first level...<br /><br />so yes, Distinction!Dylan Sterlandnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-70013358643369347002009-06-11T16:45:42.134+10:002009-06-11T16:45:42.134+10:00Loved the video, it made everything really clear. ...Loved the video, it made everything really clear. And for those who ask, 'why play a game about cleaning?', well because you can do it in ANY HAT YOU CHOOSE, the customization was great! I could really see this being an actual game.<br /><br />DistinctionTim Goschnicknoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-42034950287748104842009-06-11T13:22:35.473+10:002009-06-11T13:22:35.473+10:00My comments for this group are on my home computer...My comments for this group are on my home computer, will update tonight.Robert Sheahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/11090826561723680373noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-10027492236417853992009-06-11T12:06:11.034+10:002009-06-11T12:06:11.034+10:00The video was awesome
Presentation was clear
Bonus...The video was awesome<br />Presentation was clear<br />Bonus points for the idea that you play as your Mii character<br />Website is good - clearly explains everything - the concept, controls, characters and how your game relates to the mind/body conflict, performance etc.<br /><br />It's a Credit<br /><br />-Kalonica Quigley<br />s3237922Kalonica Quigleyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/01077160422256748707noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-36278131002415084092009-06-11T10:27:43.724+10:002009-06-11T10:27:43.724+10:00Interesting concept, brilliant video.
69/100. C.Interesting concept, brilliant video.<br /><br />69/100. C.Mark Contenoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-19371282194022737542009-06-11T09:28:56.547+10:002009-06-11T09:28:56.547+10:00Sounds all right. I mean I know theres the issue o...Sounds all right. I mean I know theres the issue of Cleaning not being something everyone wants to do but I can see where you are going with the addition of the bad kid getting to mess things up as well. However, I would really recommend more evil and conniving ways for the naughty kid in order to make the game more interesting because as you know, many people still go on with the issue of claning not being something they would like in the game and you need some kind of solid and unique gimmick to make this game truly work<br /><br />Overall: DistinctionGanhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/18156562056231965381noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-57801765398335763972009-06-11T03:56:07.237+10:002009-06-11T03:56:07.237+10:00wasnt too convinced with this game it just wasnt t...wasnt too convinced with this game it just wasnt too striking. but the video was defiantly classic <br />C<br />Damien S3235475Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-2114792386503754592009-06-11T03:28:23.805+10:002009-06-11T03:28:23.805+10:00Yeah, wasn't totally convinced by the game ini...Yeah, wasn't totally convinced by the game initially, but that video... beautiful. Brilliant job guys. I do actually think that the "cleaning made fun!" sentiment would actually be carried over to real life in some cases, and could subliminally help people become more tidy/etc. That is unless they were utterly absorbed by the game that is, and became more slovenly as a result... so maybe you should develop a threshold for the game in the case that happens, haha. Wait, lightbulb! It would be great if as well as being a game in itself, it had an "actual cleaning motivator" mode or something along those lines, wherein at certain points of the game the player has to clean parts of their home in order to activate further Cleaning Maid goodness? Don't know how that would work out logistically but food for thought nonetheless. I give you guys a HD!Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-89256500990561639912009-06-11T01:20:00.037+10:002009-06-11T01:20:00.037+10:00The video sold it for me, I don't know how man...The video sold it for me, I don't know how many people would play a cleaning game, but i think you took it the right way. I like idea of the nemesis naughty child dirtying stuff. Might get a little repetative, or RSI may set in, but nice one.<br /><br />Distinction<br /><br />Ben Goodvach-Draffin<br />3163806Ben Goodvach-Draffinnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-56578027099550338712009-06-10T23:33:50.034+10:002009-06-10T23:33:50.034+10:00Hey guys, very original idea accompanied with a hi...Hey guys, very original idea accompanied with a hilarious video. very cool stuff, the idea however was kind of marketed towards a "specialest" market in my opinion. i mean cooking mama was fun but this was... i dont know.<br /><br />Distinction<br /><br />thanks,<br />Logan<br />s3235083Logan Gray s3235083noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-61562446376023579492009-06-10T22:22:12.926+10:002009-06-10T22:22:12.926+10:00you guys rocked, and your video totally won me ove...you guys rocked, and your video totally won me over.<br />i love that you took an everyday boring thing like cleaning and made it into something fun. <br />i think it'd be tough getting people to initially give it the time of day, but if you won them over like you did with us i could see this game taking off like cooking mama.<br /><br />score: Dnikki l jacksonhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04503234919152399240noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-84992108332853439492009-06-10T22:00:56.102+10:002009-06-10T22:00:56.102+10:00@Thao Jason filmed and edited the video, I added t...@Thao Jason filmed and edited the video, I added the animationsTrevor Talbothttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08284680550147813687noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-64869857169579519472009-06-10T21:52:49.876+10:002009-06-10T21:52:49.876+10:00I'm sick of long comments so...
A fun, twist ...I'm sick of long comments so...<br /><br />A fun, twist on a boring task. Thanks for the video laughs, nice cockroaches & stuff... Not overly social or physical but not bad either. Balanced, all the same. Mind-body loop has been incorporated nicely into the game. Website is informative & full of great technical info & imagery... like the "screenshots". Overall, nice work!<br /><br />Marks<br /><br />Physical Exertion: 7/10<br />Mind Body Conflict: 8/10<br />Mind Body Loop: 9/10<br />Social: 7/10<br />Emotion: 7/10<br />Performance: 8/10<br />Originality: 8/10<br />Style: 8/10<br />Presentation: 8/10<br />Website: 8/10<br /><br />Overall, that gives you 78% which is a D100th Monkeyhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14217004200249372672noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-63973184557702473112009-06-10T21:48:53.942+10:002009-06-10T21:48:53.942+10:00I would have never thought cleaning would be fun b...I would have never thought cleaning would be fun but since you have made it into a game perhaps it could be. The video was so good, i wanted to do something similar for our own group video but the whole group didn't agree which is a pity. Overall you get a distinctionJessehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/18317465227151516348noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-80846850500513118982009-06-10T21:34:52.179+10:002009-06-10T21:34:52.179+10:00I think this game could be a fun enjoyable game, b...I think this game could be a fun enjoyable game, but I think you need to design it further. It's definitely an interesting idea to take something people usually consider a chore and try and turn it into a fun game.<br /><br />Perhaps if you made it a little more surreal. By that I mean creating more unique/less realistic situations you needed to clean in. Or creating intelligent muck or something.<br /><br />I think the control scheme is fine. I can see peoples arms getting tired really quickly! (which I think is a good thing)<br /><br />Overall I reckon the gameplay of your idea would be solid. But I think design wise it's a little bit thin.<br /><br />Great video though!<br /><br />Concept :: 5/10<br />Physical Exertion :: 6/10<br />Mind/Body Conflict Loop :: 6/10<br />Social :: 7/10<br />Emotion :: 7/10<br />Performance :: 8/10<br />Originality :: 6/10<br />Presentation :: 8/10<br />Website :: 6/10<br />Bonus :: 10/10<br />TOTAL :: 69/100 = CGeoff Walkernoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-22646887155123580452009-06-10T19:37:36.715+10:002009-06-10T19:37:36.715+10:00Hey Guys
I didn’t see this one coming…a cleaning ...Hey Guys<br /><br />I didn’t see this one coming…a cleaning game. Perfect for every female… ill be dodging bullets after that, I’m just joking girls. Anyway, the presentation was OK, website is good and I understood the game and what had to be done. My only concern is the content. I love the idea of being able to interact with your surroundings in a game, and the Wii remote might be able to make it feel a bit more ‘real’ however cleaning…I’m not too sure about that one. If I am going to clean I would rather do the work for real and have an actual clean house in the end rather than only in my game. Everything else is gr8 it just needs to hold the players interest.<br /><br />Games are a way of allowing people to do things they don’t or can’t normally do in real life. Or it helps them escape reality for a while. <br /><br />I’ve decided to ditch the mark allocation list. From the presentation and what I think I’m able to give a mark that I think is fair. <br /><br />Final mark<br /><br />C - Credit.https://www.blogger.com/profile/03695427450201413533noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-4938926045446840962009-06-10T18:03:04.147+10:002009-06-10T18:03:04.147+10:00very good work.. yes it does raise the question of...very good work.. yes it does raise the question of why would I play this game if it's about cleaning ? but that aside it seems very fun & makes good use of the wii mote & it's definitely in the vain of those "cooking mama" sort of games yes your presentation was very funny, i'm giving you a distinctionAnh-Tu S3132638https://www.blogger.com/profile/14511078969376806822noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-9524834903791664752009-06-10T16:40:22.602+10:002009-06-10T16:40:22.602+10:00The presentation was hilarious. Try to mess up you...The presentation was hilarious. Try to mess up your friends cleaning? Why not. The concept really worked well in your video and I can see it being a popular game with younger people. Also, awesome job!<br /><br />D!<br /><br />Sama(3239506)Sama Rindhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08933126429989475425noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-66024124782718250732009-06-10T15:34:28.863+10:002009-06-10T15:34:28.863+10:00Good presentation, as mentioned the video was very...Good presentation, as mentioned the video was very funny.<br /><br />I can imagine this game working very well as a large team based game, with armies of maids and bad kids. This would enhance the already good social dynamics you had set up.<br /><br />You might have trouble with the mind-body conflict - as was mentioned earlier, the reliance on aggressive hand/wrist movement could cause wrist fatigue and pain.<br /><br />CreditLisanoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-6784666120200940532009-06-10T14:59:51.656+10:002009-06-10T14:59:51.656+10:00I wanna know who did editing video clip?!! It'...I wanna know who did editing video clip?!! It's interesting and fun video!!<br />Your game is good but not enough interesting to me. Because I can do housework , so why i do play this game and spend time while i can not get any real result ( e.g. clean house and bathroom).<br />65 = C for your idea.Thao Uyen Thttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06202666918494986777noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8840029558919433184.post-69430594107897525162009-06-10T14:57:01.436+10:002009-06-10T14:57:01.436+10:00This comment has been removed by the author.Thao Uyen Thttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06202666918494986777noreply@blogger.com